Chelsea broker dies after being hit by cyclist: Police

BY LINCOLN ANDERSON | Twenty-third St. and Sixth Ave., tragically, continues to live up to its reputation as one of the city’s most dangerous intersections. A man who was struck by a cyclist there at the end of July died of his injuries earlier this week, police reported.

Michael Collopy died after being struck by a cyclist in a bike lane at Sixth Ave. and 23rd St., just a block from his home. Among other things, he was known for wearing stylish hats and also being a huge fan of the Yankees and skiing in Vermont. (Photo courtesy City Connections Realty)

Police said Michael Collopy, 60, of 170 W. 23rd St., was standing in the bike lane on Sixth Ave. at 11:53 p.m. on Wed., July 31, when he was hit by a cyclist riding northbound in the lane who did not stop or remain at the scene. 

Officers responding to a 911 call found Collopy at the location with head trauma. An E.M.S. ambulance transported him to Bellevue Medical Center, where he succumbed to his injuries on Mon., Aug. 5.

According to police, on Wed., Aug. 7, the city’s medical examiner determined his cause of death was from being struck by the cyclist. There are no arrests and the investigation is ongoing.

However, the New York Post reported that on Thursday the medical examiner said it had made no such determination, and that there was “a misunderstanding by N.Y.P.D. detectives.”

“For clarity, the cause and manner of death in this case is pending determination,” the M.E. said in a statement, the Post reported.

For the past five years, Collopy was an associate broker for residential sales with City Connections, whose office is at 71 W. 23rd St., just one block from his home and just steps away from where he was killed.

He had been a real estate broker since 2003. Prior to that, he was an auditor and also worked in finance.

Collopy was a graduate of New York University’s Stern School of Business, and got his B.A. in accounting from Fairfield University. 

Collopy’s death at the dangerous intersection came slightly more than a month after Robyn Hightman, a 20-year-old bike messenger, was killed near that spot when she was riding in traffic on the avenue and hit by a truck.

David Schlamm, president of City Connections, said Collopy was single, close to his nieces and nephews, an avid Yankees fan and frequently skied in Vermont. He said no one is sure what Collopy was doing outside the office right before he was killed.

“He was a kind, generous guy,” Schlamm said.

He said the company is trying to plan a group outing to Yankees game in the late co-worker’s honor, and they hope they’ll be able to get his photo shown on a large screen. A memorial is planned at St. Patrick’s Cathedral, on Fifth Ave., on Aug. 24 at 10 a.m.

Lien Corey, an artist who lives at 21st St. and Seventh Ave., said she witnessed Collopy splayed out on the street after he was hit, as well as the accident scene in June a few hours after Hightman was fatally struck. 

(Full disclosure: This writer is a friend of Corey’s and she had mentioned to him the previous Friday that she had seen a bloodied man lying in the bike lane who had been hit by a cyclist.)

She said the carnage at the deadly intersection has been taking an emotional toll on her. Every day, Corey, who is in her 60s, goes to 23rd St. and Sixth Ave. around noon to get a copy of the free Metro newspaper at the box outside the Citibank branch at the northwest corner.

“What I saw was an older man, probably in his 70s, with blood,” Corey said, “right in front of Citibank. He was, like, lying right in the bike lane…kind of a little bit diagonal, head toward Citibank. And hovering over him were, like, two bike messengers.

“I saw his jaw moving, so I said, ‘Good, he’s alive.’ I saw movement in his lower jaw,” she recalled.

Corey said after medics came to aid the man, she went to get some coffee at Starbucks on Sixth Ave. between 21st and 22nd Sts. 

“I just walked away,” she said. “I couldn’t take it.”

When she returned to the spot afterward, the broker had already been taken to the hospital. 

A biker herself, Corey said she was deeply affected by Hightman’s death on June 24, particularly by seeing a pool of blood on the street at the scene. Then seeing blood, once again, a month later, around the gravely injured man’s head was overwhelming for her.

“I just saw blood flowing,” she said of Collopy, “and I was absolutely distraught because when that girl died, I just cried and cried. The bike was still there [in the street], her helmet was still there, blood was still there.

“I bike all the time,” Corey said. “I thought, ‘It could be me.’ I’ve been hit a couple of times. There’s always some reckless driver. They don’t see you or they open their door and hit you.”

She said the Chelsea/Flatiron intersection simply is very dangerous, but that cyclists also must ride more carefully.

“Twenty-third and Sixth is very deadly,” she said. “These cyclists, they are either killing themselves or killing others. The messengers, they’re just trying to get where they’re going. They’re not paying attention.”

Corey said she witnessed an intense moment after leaving the scene of Hightman’s death. She went into the Doughnut Plant, the only ground-floor commercial tenant in the currently under-renovation Hotel Chelsea, to get a donut. She said the driver who hit Hightman then happened to pull up his box truck right outside the shop.

“There was a swarm of bikers and they tried to pull the guy out,” she said. “There was a lot of police and they got the bikers away. I saw the bikers. They were very, very upset.”

Corey said the fatal intersection has gotten extremely crowded due to a surge in foot traffic, which she feels is definitely a factor in the accidents and fatalities.

“I think it’s the sheer amount of people,” she said, adding, “Have you ever been on 23rd St. at lunchtime?”

With that many people, she noted, it’s simply “the law of averages” that serious problems are going to happen.

According to Streetsblog, since 2016, the intersection at W. 23rd St. and Sixth Ave. has seen six cyclists, 18 pedestrians and 15 drivers injured. The cycling-advocacy blog said that, annually, in New York City, less than one pedestrian is killed by cyclists, while 138 pedestrians are killed by cars. 

In yet another traffic fatality in Chelsea, police reported that on Thurs., Aug. 8, pedestrian Iris Crespo, 77, of 60 Amsterdam Ave., was killed by a yellow cab driver at Eighth Ave. and 22nd St. at 5:02 p.m. The hack, Daniel Fusaro, 82, continued to drive north until hitting a parked car. He was charged with leaving the scene of an accident, failure to yield to a pedestrian, failure to obey a traffic signal and failure to exercise due care.

Correction: Due to incorrect information in a police report, this article initially listed Michael Collopy’s address as 170 W. 123rd St. He lived at 170 W. 23rd St.

8 Responses to Chelsea broker dies after being hit by cyclist: Police

  1. A spokesperson for the medical examiner told Streetsblog on Thursday that police were “incorrect.”

    “The ME has not yet made a determination (decided cause/manner of death) in this case,” Aja Worthy-Davis said. She added that she would begin reaching out to local reporters who had also published the NYPD’s version of the events.

    Indeed, late on Thursday afternoon, Worthy-Davis sent the following email to multiple media outlets.

    It has come to my attention that recent media coverage that covered the death of Michael Collopy stated that the case Medical Examiner (forensic pathologist) made a determination regarding the cause and manner of death.

    For clarity, the cause and manner of death in this case is pending determination.

    We’d ask that you make this correction in your coverage.

    NYPD spokesman Sgt. Vincent Marchese could not explain the discrepancy on Thursday and declined to respond to Worthy-Davis’s direct challenge to the NYPD’s version of events.

    “According to the report, this is what we have,” Marchese said. The NYPD had also said Collopy was a Harlem resident, but neighbors at the building where he supposedly lived did not know him and the building super told Streetsblog that no building resident had recently died. Other media outlets said Collopy lived in Chelsea, near where he was allegedly hit.

    https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2019/08/08/medical-examiner-nypd-is-incorrect-that-cyclist-killed-pedestrian/

  2. I saw the story on the tv news.
    Other witnesses reported seeing a cyclist involved in the hit and run.
    The hyper pro-bike idiots can no longer say that only cars kill people. This death is #2 this year. Deblasio, get off your philosophical “cyclists can do no wrong” holy ass, and start ticketing the reckless moronic cyclists among us.
    (Reckless pedestrians can use a ticket as well.)

  3. Perry Rothenberg

    Big problem; Bike people who are reckless and come at you from all directions

    with no regard to pedestrians and traffic signals. This was a hit and run

    crime. Hope this biker gets caught and prosecuted.

  4. Thank you for posting this. It is so sad. This is indeed the other side of the coin that no one speaks of. Every day I dodge these lunatics on the sidewalk, running red lights, turning the wrong way. Bicyclists need regulation.

  5. In studies done with rats, it has been found there are more fatalities in overcrowded conditions. The same goes for people and that’s what we’re seeing now. Building and building, never ending, will do it. The real estate industry and our electing officials who are allowing this, should be brought up on manslaughter charges.

  6. I wonder what Ellen McDermott and her band of Trump-like bike enthusiasts think about this now. These bike lanes are extremely dangerous and since the city put no thought into planning them, have led to pedestrian deaths. Cory Johnson should be impeached and Ellen McDermott should be forced to resign

  7. This is terrible (of course), and I will repeat that every bicyclist has a responsibility to be mindful and considerate of pedestrians at all times. That said, a few points.

    First, please note that the medical examiner is disputing the police account that Michael Collopy died as a result of being struck. And, secondly, that he was standing in the bike lane. Not that that should be a death sentence, but pedestrians also have responsibilities.

    And finally: He is the third pedestrian killed by a cyclist in NYC in as many years. There have already been 88 New Yorkers (including 18 bicyclists) killed by motorists so far this year. The most recent cyclist to die was Em Samolewicz, 30, an art teacher, struck by a truck in Sunset Park July 29. Because a vehicle door was opening in the bike lane, and she was forced to swerve into the traffic.

    Even those few deaths attributed to bicyclists take place in the context of streets dominated by toxin-belching death machines. I look forward to the day that bicyclists and pedestrians unite against the common and far greater threat: cars.

  8. The city will, no doubt, hide this statistic. I have never seen them release stats on how many people get hit by cyclists. A former coworker got hit by a cyclist and had to have surgery.

    Cyclists are an active and loud group and because of this deBlasio and the City Council cow tow to them. Anyone who is on the street sees cyclists blowing through red lights all day long. There are no crack downs. Cyclists have become a menace. There are so many now, they should have to have license plate that get read by traffic cameras, and be sent tickets if they blow through red lights, just like car drivers do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *