OPINION: A turn for the worse: Truck trashes tree on 12th

BY ELISSA STEIN | On Fri., July 13, a significant chunk of a statuesque tree in front of 79 W. 12th St. was shorn off by a truck that didn’t successful make the turn off Sixth Ave.

This was not the first time the tree had been hit, and the next day the city marked it to be taken down, saying it was too weak to survive the accident. The awning in front of the building was irreparably damaged by the heavy branch’s fall and needs to be replaced, as well.

According to the city’s Department of Transportation, it is illegal for trucks of this size to be driving on side streets. But, there’s no signage on 12th St. stating that, and since there is little visible regulation by the police or D.O.T., large trucks traversing side streets happens on a regular basis.

A truck, which was not even supposed to be on 12th St., wrecked this tree near Sixth Ave. (Photo by Elissa Stein)

So now, one of the Village’s tree-lined blocks will have a gaping hole, which will take years to fill.

This unfortunate accident, in which fortunately no one was injured, leads to bigger questions and highlights serious issues. As of now, the city plans to move forward with an experimental (their word) 14th St. “busway/truckway,” which includes a vehicle ban on cars traveling across the city between Ninth and Third Aves. on 14th St. This will result in through traffic being shunted to side streets. Since 12th and 13th Sts. are the closest to 14th St. that run from river to river, they will absorb much of the overflow.

In addition to that dramatic increase in traffic, vehicles now cannot make left turns from 14th St., so trucks have been, and will continue to use side streets for that purpose. Currently there is a temporary restraining order against the busway plan in effect until Aug. 6, when a hearing is scheduled to determine whether to issue a preliminary injunction.

While the city and monied forces beyond are working hard to vilify cars, there are key points that are buried underneath their “bikeways and PeopleWays for everyone” rhetoric.

First, Manhattan is an island and vehicles are necessary to bring goods to stores, and provide services to business and residents. This borough is home to residents of mansions as well as city housing projects, those who can easily take mass transportation and others who cannot, people who ride bikes and people who use wheelchairs, a destination for commuters and a home to residents.

This flippant attempt to cut traffic congestion in order to shave a few minutes off travel time has made our streets more dangerous. The death of a beautiful tree is a shame. But incidents and accidents are becoming more commonplace and the mayor and D.O.T. need to listen to people who are the most affected.

Stein is a Village resident, writer and community activist.

3 Responses to OPINION: A turn for the worse: Truck trashes tree on 12th

  1. Unintended consequences of entirely predictable results.

    What could possibly happen when you restrict truck traffic on a major, designated, cross-town truck route. It's not like they'll find other close by routes, right?

    Thank goodness it wasn't a tragic result either in the bike lane or the sidewalk or the traffic lane.

    • The 14 street bus and truck priority allows trucks to travel on 14 street so where is the restriction of truck route you are referring to?

      The real RasonMustWin

  2. Elissa, what happened here?

    We said we are going to publish this OpEd AFTER the city will put the 14 street people way in place.

    Now it shows that trucks are traveling illegally on 12th street although 14 Street is still a free for all through way. We need to coordinate better.

    Also, DOT does not do enforcement, only NYPD.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *